Join The Discussion!
My readers' replies to my Columns keep me on my toes and inspire new topics!
From Yankee Doodle's Cockade: Reader Doug noted that some sources say "macaroni" actually refers to a type of fashion or fashionable men during the 1770s. I too had run across this explanation for the term in the song but feel it's not the correct one.
My first reason is that the Macaronis were men, not "things." The song says Yankee Doodle called his feather the "macaroni," not himself.
My second reason is that the context of the song doesn't seem to fit what the Macaronis were all about. The song is characterizing Yankee Doodle as a country bumpkin, so it seems a far stretch to imply that he would even know what the Macaronis were, much less be imitating them. He would far more likely despise the Macaronis, since they were characterized as being effeminate fops.
Of course, this is just my opinion, but I felt that in context of the song "macaroni" better fit the slang for "military brass" than "effeminate fop."
Thanks, Doug, for bringing up this interesting tidbit!