Dear Colleague: For this month, the NEARI Press newsletter article examined the concept of grooming. While grooming may be a popular concept, the aut

   
NEARI Press Masthead with Photos

Dear Colleague:
For this month, the NEARI Press newsletter article examined the concept of grooming. While grooming may be a popular concept, the authors note there is no common definition or any validation to allow it to be accurately applied to an investigative setting. It is also problematic because many of the behaviors described as grooming are also ways that healthy adults interact in a positive ways with the children they care for. So while “grooming” may seem obvious in hindsight, there is no valid way at this time to use this in forensic investigations.

We chose to highlight this article because grooming is so often discussed as a fully accepted approach to identifying adults who sexually abuse children. We hope that it will be used with caution until it is more fully researched and more deeply understood.

As always, if you have any other questions or suggestions for future newsletter topics, please don't hesitate to contact us.

Sincerely,
Joan Tabachnick
NEARI Press

***

What We Know (And Don’t Know) About “Grooming” Behaviors

by David S. Prescott and Joan Tabachnick

Authors
Natalie Bennett and William O’Donohue

The Question
How can the concept of “grooming” be used effectively in prevention and forensic work?

The Research
Since the 1980s, researchers have suggested that adults who sexually abuse a child will often employ a “seduction stage” often known as “grooming” before they harm the child. Grooming is understood as a process to identify a particularly vulnerable child, gain access to that child, and prepare that child to be compliant with the abuse.

In their article, Natalie Bennett and William O’Donohue carefully review the literature regarding grooming and note there is a lack of consensus regarding the grooming process and how it is clearly distinguished from healthy adult-child interactions. For example, buying gifts for a child or taking them on private outings are often behaviors that adults will naturally do with children they care about. The authors suggest that if a consistent grooming process could be identified, it would allow professionals to identify this behavior and intervene before a child is harmed. Additionally, in a forensic context, sexual abuse allegations could be at least partially substantiated if it could be established that grooming was in fact, intentional. However, without a clear and consistent definition and a way of measuring this behavior, any practical use is at best problematic.

Based upon the major commonalities in definitions, the authors proposed the following: Grooming can be defined as “antecedent inappropriate behavior that functions to increase the likelihood of future sexual abuse.” The criteria to be met therefore includes: 1) behavior must in and of itself be inappropriate and a case for this inappropriateness must be made, and 2) a sound argument must be presented that the behavior(s) increases the likelihood of future sexual abuse. The authors then describe some examples of grooming behaviors and note the more of these features that are present, the more likely that a child or teen is being groomed. These features include:
* Any sexualization of a relationship between adult and child or teen
* Inappropriate gift giving, e.g., bikinis or bras purchased by a neighbor or teacher
* Age-inappropriate nonsexual communication with a child, e.g., telling him or her that they are the only one who can really understand the adult
* Inappropriate or excessive touching of the child or teen
* Bribes in exchange for inappropriate contact
* Boundary violations
* Asking a child or teen to keep secrets
* And many others

The authors recognize that the term “inappropriate” is somewhat vague and requires some judgement. They also acknowledge that some inappropriate behaviors may not be grooming behaviors at all. Finally, the authors suggest that validity studies be conducted to see the extent to which trained professionals can correctly identify these behaviors.

Bottom Line: While grooming may be a popular concept, there is no common definition or any validation to allow it to be accurately applied to an investigative setting.

Implications for Professionals
Many authors have attempted to bring about clarity in what “grooming” actually is, and as mentioned by the authors, it is problematic on many levels. Not only is the term vague but so are many of the behavioral examples used by anyone talking about this term. Given the current use of “grooming” to describe sex offending behaviors, the authors’ attempts at clarification are praiseworthy. However, it is worthwhile to note that many of the studies they relied on are from the 1980s. One wonders if it is not a dated concept in its current form. Recent research has shown that the goals and motivations underlying grooming can vary widely and that pre-offense processes are not necessarily explicit or planned.

Further, the concept of grooming as an explicit process rarely takes into account what is now known about both static and dynamic risk factors. If the purpose of refining the concept of “grooming” is to identify imminent abuse before it happens, then incorporating the current research about risk factors to offend and re-offend would be helpful. Finally, there is no mention of how grooming behaviors may vary from culture to culture and how some of the social norms of one culture may skew how behaviors are viewed by another culture.

Implications for the Field
There is no question that grooming is a popular concept in the media, for individuals interested in this issue and among many professionals. It is often fairly easy, in retrospect, to see the signs that one comes to believe were obvious clues. However, some of those behaviors may also be clues to healthy parenting. We agree with the authors that the popularity of the vague notion of grooming makes further empirical study all the more necessary. Because grooming implies intent, more research on the processes underlying overt behaviors is needed. In the meantime, organizations (including but not limited to those that serve youth) have both an opportunity and an obligation to establish clear social norms, codes of conduct, and expectation around behaviors--making it harder for individuals to step outside of a clear set of behavioral expectations and an established response by an organization to these violations.

Abstract
There have been claims that some child molesters engage in a “seduction stage” prior to committing abuse. These behaviors, commonly known as “grooming,” are understood as methods child molesters use to gain access to and prepare future victims to be compliant with abuse. However, there is a lack of consensus regarding exactly what this process entails and how it is clearly distinguished from normal adult-child interactions. It is important to devise an accurate definition of grooming for scientific, clinical, and forensic purposes. We critically evaluate the various definitions and reveal problematic heterogeneity. Furthermore, there are no methods of known psychometrics to validly assess grooming. We review the empirical literature regarding the occurrence of grooming and propose future directions for research.

Citation
Bennett, N. & O’Donohue, W. (2015). The construct of grooming in child sexual abuser conceptual and measurement issues. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse. DOI: 10.1080/10538712.2014.960632.

To print a pdf of this article, click NEARI NEWS.

***

FEATURED NEARI RESOURCES

Book Very-Different Voices

Very Different Voices: Perspectives and Case Studies in Treating Sexual Aggression

by David S. Prescott and Robin J. Wilson

The referral that just crossed your desk has left you scratching your head. You've never seen a client with these issues before and, frankly, it's unclear where to start. This new book brings insights from many internationally known experts, sharing what works and what doesn't with a wide range of clients experiencing sexual behavior problems and related clinical conundrums. Beyond the research studies readily available in the scholarly literature, this book offers practical models for clinicians working at the individual level, and illustrates many of the challenges that clients and therapists alike can face.

227 pages
ISBN: 978-1929657797
Catalog Number: 9726
Price: $28.00 plus shipping and handling

***

BECOME A WEBINAR SERIES SPONSOR

neari 2015 catalog thumb

NEW 2015-2016 Catalog

Please consider becoming a sponsor of NEARIPress.org's exciting new 2016 NEARI Press Webinar series. And if you join now, you will get the remaining webinar in June for free! We will continue to feature nationally recognized authors of NEARI Press and others willing to share their emerging research and cutting edge practice.

For $98 as an individual or $250 as an organization, we will guarantee your seat in the webinar AND offer you CE credits. We do all of the work to sign you up each month, and, as a thank you for your essential support, we offer you two free NEARI Press books – Current Perspectives and Current Applications, both edited by David Prescott and Robert Longo. We think that this is really a win-win situation for all of us.

For more information or to sign up, visit our website at info@nearipress.org or contact Diane Langelier at 413.540.0712 x14 or email her at info@nearipress.org.

CONSIDER JOINING US FOR A FUTURE WEBINAR

Please consider joining us for one of our webinars in the 2016 Series. All of these are recorded, so if you missed one that is important to you, visit our website and see these thought-provoking talks at a time and place that suits you!

All webinars begin at 3:00 p.m. Eastern Standard Time and run for One Hour.

May 10, 17, 24: Juvenile Sexual Risk Assessment: An Overview in Three Parts; Phil Rich, EdD, small fee will be charged for this three-part webinar series).
June 14: Consultinar; David Prescott, LICSW

***

DONATE NOW TO NEARI PRESS

NEARI Press is a nonprofit and depends upon the support of professionals like you to continue our work. Please consider giving a donation to NEARI Press.

Click here to make a donation of any amount. Thank you!

***

QUESTIONS/FEEDBACK

Please email us at info@nearipress.org or call us at 413.540.0712, x14 to let us know if you have a question or a topic you would like us to cover.

If at any time you no longer want the e-newsletter, just let us know and we will remove your name from our list. We value your trust. We will not sell or give your contact information to any other organization.

Volume 9, Issue 4: April 2016

1px